Next available appointments

Times may vary. Displayed times are for in-person visits. Additional times may be available for both new and current patients.

Fri, 1/02

  • 7:15 AM
  • 11:15 AM
  • 12:45 PM

Tue, 1/20

  • 8:00 AM
  • 1:00 PM

Wed, 1/28

  • 11:15 AM

Locations of Cory Nathan Costello, MD

Biography

Dr. Costello is board-certified in family medicine. He provides personalized, compassionate care. Dr. Costello offers a wide range of primary care services, including the management of hypertension, diabetes, thyroid and ... cholesterol. He has strong experience in preventive medicine.

Dr. Costello is fluent in English and has a working proficiency in Spanish. He is a combat veteran, published clinical researcher, and experienced military chief medical officer from serving our nation and NATO.
He enjoys his spare time with his wife and family of four children.

View More
Ages Seen
Adolescents (ages 12-18)
Adults
Geriatrics
Language(s) Spoken
English
Education
Medical School: New York Medical College (1996)
Internship: General Surgery, Eisenhower Army Medical Center (1997)
Residency: Family Medicine, Darnall Army Comm Hospital (2003)
Medical School: Darnall Army Comm Hospital (2003)
Certifications
Family Medicine- American Board of Family Medicine
Hospital Affiliations
Baylor Scott & White Medical Center - Centennial

Insurances accepted

Baylor Scott & White has established agreements with several types of insurance to ensure your health needs are covered.

Insurance listings are subject to change without prior notice.

 
By searching you agree to these terms
  • Aetna - (12)
    Aetna-Aetna Signature Administrators
    Aetna-Choice POS II
    Aetna-Health Network Only
    Aetna-Health Network Option
    Aetna-HMO
    Aetna-Managed Choice
    Aetna-Open Access Elect Choice
    Aetna-Open Access Managed Choice
    Aetna-Open Access Select
    Aetna-Open Choice PPO
    Aetna-QPOS
    Aetna-Select
  • Baylor Scott & White Health Plan - (25)
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Access PPO
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Extended PPO
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Plus HMO-Group
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Plus HMO-Individual/Family
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Plus PPO-Group
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Plus PPO-Individual/Family
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Preferred HMO - Individual Marketplace
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Preferred HMO Network - Group
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Preferred PPO Network
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Premier HMO-Group
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Premier HMO-Individual/Family
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Premier PPO
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW SeniorCare Advantage HMO
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW SeniorCare Advantage PPO
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSW Solutions PPO
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSWH Employee Network (SEQA & EQA)
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-BSWH Employee Network Premium (PPO)/ HDHP
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-Covenant Preferred HMO
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-EPO Network-Individual/Family
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-Hendrick Health Employee Plan
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-HMO Network-Group
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-HMO Network-Individual/Family
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-McLane Group Network
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-PPO Network-Group
    Baylor Scott & White Health Plan-Pyco Industries Employee Plan
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield - (26)
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Advantage - Bronze
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Advantage - Gold
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Advantage - Silver
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Advantage Plus - Bronze
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Advantage Plus - Gold
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Advantage Plus - Silver
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Choice
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Cross Group Medicare Advantage (PPO)
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Cross Medicare Advantage (HMO)
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Cross Medicare Advantage Dual Care Plus (HMO SNP)
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Cross Medicare Advantage Value (HMO)
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Essentials
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Essentials Access
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Premier
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Blue Premier Access
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Consumer Directed HealthSelect
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Federal Basic Option
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Federal FEP Blue Focus
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-Federal Standard Option
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-High Performance Network
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-MA Oncor/NRG Futr Hold Retire PPO
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-TRS-ActiveCare 2
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-TRS-ActiveCare Primary
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-TRS-ActiveCare Primary HD
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-TRS-ActiveCare Primary+
    Blue Cross Blue Shield-TRS-Care Standard
  • Catalyst Health Group - (1)
    Catalyst Health Group-Catalyst Health - Baylor Scott & White Preferred
  • Centivo Network - (1)
    Centivo Network-Centivo Network - Baylor Scott & White Premier
  • Cigna - (7)
    Cigna-BSW Extended PPO
    Cigna-Choice Fund
    Cigna-HMO Open Access
    Cigna-LocalPlus
    Cigna-LocalPlus In-Network
    Cigna-Open Access Plus
    Cigna-Open Access Plus In-Network
  • DFW ConnectedCare - (1)
    DFW ConnectedCare-American Airlines Employee Benefit Plan
  • EHN - (1)
    EHN-Employers Health Network
  • HealthSmart - (2)
    HealthSmart-Accel Network
    HealthSmart-Preferred Network
  • Humana - (11)
    Humana-ChoiceCare
    Humana-Humana Gold Choice (PFFS)
    Humana-Humana Gold Plus (HMO)
    Humana-Humana Gold Plus SNP-DE (HMO D-SNP)
    Humana-Humana Honor (PPO)
    Humana-Humana Preferred
    Humana-Humana USAA Honor with Rx (PPO)
    Humana-HumanaChoice (PPO)
    Humana-HumanaChoice (Regional PPO)
    Humana-National POS
    Humana-PPO
  • Imagine Health - (1)
    Imagine Health-Imagine Health Network
  • Medicaid - (2)
    Medicaid-Superior HealthPlan
    Medicaid-Traditional Medicaid
  • Medicare - (1)
    Medicare-Traditional Medicare
  • Nebraska Furniture Mart - (3)
    Nebraska Furniture Mart-Emerald
    Nebraska Furniture Mart-Onyx
    Nebraska Furniture Mart-Pearl
  • PHCS Network - (1)
    PHCS Network-PHCS Primary PPO
  • Prism Electric - (1)
    Prism Electric-BSW Premier - Prism
  • Superior Health Plan - (3)
    Superior Health Plan-Ambetter Core EPO - Bronze
    Superior Health Plan-Ambetter Core EPO - Gold
    Superior Health Plan-Ambetter Core EPO - Silver
  • TriWest HealthCare - (1)
    TriWest HealthCare-VA-PCCC
  • United HealthCare - (28)
    United HealthCare-All Savers
    United HealthCare-Charter
    United HealthCare-Charter Balanced
    United HealthCare-Charter Plus
    United HealthCare-Choice
    United HealthCare-Choice Plus
    United HealthCare-Core
    United HealthCare-Core Essential
    United HealthCare-EDGE
    United HealthCare-Erickson Advantage Champion (HMO-POS C-SNP)
    United HealthCare-Erickson Advantage Freedom (HMO-POS)
    United HealthCare-Erickson Advantage Guardian (HMO-POS I-SNP)
    United HealthCare-Erickson Advantage Liberty with Drugs (HMO-POS)
    United HealthCare-Erickson Advantage Liberty without Drugs (HMO-POS)
    United HealthCare-Erickson Advantage Signature with Drugs (HMO-POS
    United HealthCare-Navigate
    United HealthCare-Navigate Balanced
    United HealthCare-Navigate Plus
    United HealthCare-Nexus ACO - Open Access
    United HealthCare-Nexus ACO - Referral Required
    United HealthCare-Options
    United HealthCare-Select
    United HealthCare-Select Plus
    United HealthCare-Surest
    United HealthCare-UnitedHealthcare Assisted Living Plan (PPO I-SNP)
    United HealthCare-UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (PPO)
    United HealthCare-UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage Choice (Regional PPO)
    United HealthCare-UnitedHealthcare Nursing Home Plan (PPO I-SNP)
  • WellMed - (15)
    WellMed-AARP Medicare Advantage (HMO-POS)
    WellMed-AARP Medicare Advantage (HMO)
    WellMed-AARP Medicare Advantage Choice (PPO)
    WellMed-AARP Medicare Advantage Patriot (HMO-POS)
    WellMed-AARP Medicare Advantage SecureHorizons Plan 1 (HMO-POS)
    WellMed-AARP Medicare Advantage SecureHorizons Plan 2 (HMO-POS)
    WellMed-AARP Medicare Advantage Walgreens (PPO)
    WellMed-UnitedHealthcare Dual Complete (HMO DSNP)
    WellMed-UnitedHealthcare Dual Complete Choice (Regional PPO DSNP)
    WellMed-UnitedHealthcare Dual Complete Select (HMO POS DSNP)
    WellMed-UnitedHealthcare Group Medicare Advantage (HMO)
    WellMed-UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage Ally (HMO POS CSNP)
    WellMed-UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage Choice (Regional PPO)
    WellMed-UnitedHealthcare Medicare Gold (Regional PPO CSNP)
    WellMed-UnitedHealthcare Medicare Silver (Regional PPO CSNP)
We’re sorry!

We couldn’t find any results for ""

Let’s tailor your healthcare to you.

Use MyBSWHealth to get a personalized care experience.

Create a MyBSWHealth account

Patient Ratings (1054)

The patient rating score is an average of all responses to physician-related questions on our nationally recognized Press Ganey Patient Satisfaction Survey .

4.9 overall patient satisfaction
averageRating metric
4.7
Wait Time at Clinic
4.9
Friendliness/Courtesy of Care Provider
4.8
Time Care Provider spent with Patient
4.9
Provider showed concern
4.9
Provider included you in decisions
4.9
Rate Care Provider

Patient Comments (520)

Overview of patient comments

Summary created using AI

Patients appreciate

Dr. Cory Costello receives overwhelmingly positive feedback from patients who consistently praise his exceptional bedside manner, personality, and interpersonal skills. Patients frequently describe him as friendly, upbeat, energetic, and genuinely caring, with many noting his positive energy makes visits enjoyable rather than stressful. His listening skills are highlighted extensively, with patients appreciating that he takes time to hear their concerns without rushing them and makes them feel valued rather than like just another appointment. Patients commend his thoroughness, professionalism, and medical knowledge, noting he explains conditions and treatments clearly in understandable terms. Many reviewers mention his ability to remember personal details about patients and their families from previous visits, which makes them feel truly cared for. His sense of humor and ability to put patients at ease, even during difficult health situations, is repeatedly praised as a rare and valuable quality.

Patients also share

While the vast majority of reviews are highly positive, a few patients identified areas for improvement. Several reviewers mentioned that Dr. Costello's high energy level, while generally appreciated, could occasionally be overwhelming, with one patient requesting he "dial it back just a couple of notches." A few patients noted instances where they felt rushed or wished they could spend more time with him during visits, acknowledging this may reflect broader healthcare system constraints rather than the provider's preference. One patient described an initial interaction where Dr. Costello spoke at length without allowing for patient response until later in the visit, though the experience improved afterward. A couple of reviews mentioned delays in joining virtual appointments or waiting in exam rooms, and one patient expressed frustration about difficulty getting responses to follow-up messages through the patient portal after testing was ordered.

Patient comments are gathered from our Press Ganey Patient Satisfaction Survey and are displayed in their entirety. Patients are de-identified for confidentiality and patient privacy.